I’ve written about my love for peanut butter. Today I’ll share, mostly in photographs, an updated - you might say sophisticated - peanut butter sandwich I created last week when I learned it was National Peanut Butter day.
Think about it. Peanut butter doesn’t really sound like it should go with jelly. But it does. Keep an open mind when you play with your food. This was a tasty treat, even though the ingredients may not sound like they go together. Use this recipe as inspiration to put your own spin on a time-honored classic sammie.
Here are the ingredients I chose to update my Peanut Butter Sammie:
I typically like Simply Jif peanut butter, it has a bit less fat, salt, etc. But Sam’s Club only had a two pack of original Jif.
Ingredients
Whole wheat sandwich thins or bagel thins. Any crusty bread you’d like to toast will work.
Peanut Butter. Creamy or crunchy. It’s your sammie!
Bacon. I like mine center cut and crisp (thus the cute bacon press).
Sun dried Tomatoes. A splash of olive oil to saute.
Jalapeno Pepper slices. (Not pictured. Added after first bite. It is an option, but it really added a nice kick of flavor!).
Fry your bacon to your liking. Again, I like mine crisp. I used three pieces of center cut bacon per sammie. Drain well.

Choose a sammie holder, aka bread:
Toast your chosen bread option. strictly optional, however, I really like how it melts the peanut butter. Note, if you choose a bagel thin, the sammie will drip a bit of peanut butter goodness. Have napkins ready!
While the bread is toasting and bacon is frying, saute the sun dried tomatoes in a splash of olive oil on medium heat. This just takes a minute or two. I happen to like mine a bit blackened.
When your sammie bread is toasted, slather with peanut butter. I did both sides. Again, it is your sammie!
Add the drained bacon, sun dried tomatoes and jalapeno peppers (or any other ingredient you’d like).

Slice and enjoy!
It really has a gourmet cafe flavor. Don’t be scared to try new combinations.I can imagine grilled chicken, portabella mushrooms, a slice of roasted turkey or ham would work well on this sammie too. Peanut butter makes everything better!
Once you try this sammie, let me know what you think. If you add other ingredients, I’d love to know.









Unfortunately, we are a peanut butter free family (3 with confirmed the hard way allergies.) But this idea is totally intriguing. I’ve never really thought about peanut butter with anything other than good old grape jelly, a childhood staple. Your creation looks really good!
I always feel bad when I learn of those with nut allergies. I would be so sad to have my peanut butter and almonds taken from me. Of course, to protect my family, I’d do it but it would be hard.
I’m intrigued. I’m a big fan of PB, but a little frightened to branch out into a bacon and PB sandwich. But like you, the bacon would have to be crisp!
Melissa, honestly, you should try the combo! I turned my nose up to it too when my favorite burger joint (Crave in Castle Rock) offered the Nutty Professor burger (my fave now!). Same ingredients minus the sun dried tomatoes and the added ground sirloin burger. It is a wicked good combo. If you don’t love sun dried, leave them off, maybe sub something else.
I love peanut butter in savory ways. I love the bacon idea, but I’m not sure I would have thought to use sundrieds. Very interesting idea.
Catherine, I love the first sentence in your reply! Try it! Mix it up. My point was to allow us to think a bit outside the normal sandwich but not so far off the beaten path.
When I was a kid, my mom always put peanut butter on our BLTs. I just thought that’s how everybody made them! It was really good. I highly recommend it! So I’m not surprised that this sandwich is good!
Peanut butter on a BLT (instead of the mayo?). Hmmm. One of my favorite sammies, I’ll try it. Thanks, Meghan!
hahahah who made up national peanut butter month??? i have pb every day so i guess i’ll have to think of something extra special to do this month in addition maybe some peaunt butter ice cream? xoxoxoshelley
Peanut butter ice cream, yum. With chocolate fudge. I see nothing wrong with that logic!